I had a show on Saturday at a Mexican restaurant that has comedy every weekend. It was packed… packed with mostly rednecks (except for about 10-15 people), but nevertheless, it was packed. It was a fun show, and Al Goodwin, who books the show, is cool.
I had a good set, but I could tell that there were certain things you couldn’t say to them. For example, I started doing a new joke of mine about a car that I saw which had a bumper sticker that read “Abortion causes breast cancer.” But something weird happened. Normally, as soon as I say that line, I can look at people and see that they realize how ridiculous that is, and they’re ready for the joke. But I looked at these people, and they were all looking at me like, “Yeah, we know abortion causes breast cancer. That’s a fact. My brother’s a scientist. He told me that!” So I aborted the joke (no pun intended). I can’t understand why anyone could accept the idea that abortion causes breast cancer, but I’m convinced that they did. If you’re making that bumper sticker, why reach that far? Just go for ovarian cancer. It sounds slightly more believable. But breast cancer? Those pipes aren’t even connected. It’s a “don’t wear contacts or you might sprain your ankle” situation. Go for pink-eye. Sounds more plausible.
Other things from the show…
There were three girls sitting in front of the comics’ table. One was normal. The other two felt the need to high-five each other after every joke they liked. Then, one time, they missed on the high five, and to reconcile, they kissed. I didn’t know high-fives and lesbian kisses were equal. Everyone was confused.
There was a guy who watched the whole show standing up. When he laughed, his whole body doubled over. You could tell how well you were doing by measuring how far he would bend. I’m not lying when I say that he touched the floor with his hands twice. This and the high-five girls are two things that happen when you mix comedy and Mexican restaurants.
After the show, the owner came up to me, and this is after I had made his patrons laugh for 25 minutes straight, and said “You shouldn’t read from notes on stage. It looks corny.” It didn’t come out like this, but the message of my reply was, “I didn’t have notes on stage. I had a set list because I was doing a lot of new stuff, and if you had a stool on stage, instead of a kid’s chair that I had to bend down to reach, no one would have noticed that I was looking at it. On top of that, if people are laughing, who cares?” But what I wanted to say was, “You know what else looks corny? Two giant palm trees on the stage that are wearing sombreros. I think that looks a little corny. Also, the fact that you’re Palestinian and own a Mexican restaurant is a little corny. Palestinians and Mexicans aren’t even similar."
Other stuff…
I have to admit that Dane Cook is the best and most innovative marketer in all of comedy. He’s also a master of the performance style of “talk loud and fast while jumping around and people will laugh.”
Before I did comedy, I thought Dane Cook was great. He was on the same level as Mitch Hedberg in my mind. Then, once I started doing standup, I listened to Dane and was like, “Where are the funny parts? He’s just talking about things that used to exist and saying, ‘Wasn’t that cool?” It's all safe, easy concepts… except when he is "influenced by" brilliant comics.
I had refused to listen to Dane’s new cd until Saturday because he bumped me from a show one time, knew that it was me that he bumped and didn’t apologize at all. Instead, he tried to sell me his headshot for $15. But, someone loaned the cd to me and I was on the road, so I popped it in. He opened the cd with a Louis CK joke that Louis has been doing for years. I finished the first of his 2 disc album and couldn’t listen any longer to his continuous string of hypotheticals, “Wouldn’t it be cool if you had a monkey/ cement truck/ were in a heist/did something crazy/ someone shit on the coats at a party/were abducted by aliens…” That’s all it was – “Wouldn’t it be cool if…” and “Remember unicorns? Weren’t they awesome?” He's right. It would be cool to have a monkey, but everyone knows that.
Background: Louis CK is a great writer and comic. He’s won at least one emmy, but I think it’s more like five. He was head writer for The Chris Rock Show, Late Night with Conan O’Brien, The Chevy Chase Show, and many others. He has 2 or 3 HBO specials and two Comedy Central specials, as well as his own HBO series which is currently in production. He also wrote Pooty Tang. Comics love him because all of his material is genius. Don’t believe me? Go to www.louisck.com .
That night, I was talking to another comic who mentioned that on the other Dane Cook disc, he ripped two more of Louis’ jokes and directed me to a website where people were talking about it. I checked it out, as well as the jokes… they were 100% Louis CK jokes.
I went to the website he was talking about, which is http://www.aspecialthing.com/phpbb/portal.php . It’s a comedy message board, with regular posts from Louis CK, Patton Oswalt and many others. The thread where Louis addresses this is called “Dane Cook: Joke Thief?”
Here are some quotes from that site:
“I gotta say. I love Dane Cook. His album is like Denis Learys "No Cure For Cancer". Louis CK is great too, but Dane Cook. What a guilty pleasure. Why doesn't he have his own show yet?”
– Dane Cook fan.
The funny thing about that is that the Leary album he’s talking about is famous for containing material stolen from Bill Hicks, another comedy legend. Not good judgment on that fan’s part.
“Last night Louis CK said something like "you probably like [Dane Cook] because he reminded you about how there used to be slippity slides"
- Someone who overheard Louis talking to a Dane Cook fan at the Laugh Factory. See what I wrote above.
“I like the way he says ‘face’.”
– A comic, whose name I will not mention because I'm not sure if it's okay to talk about Dane Cook, told me that someone told him that they like Dane Cook for that reason. I wish that was made up.
“he also has a bit on this cd called "Itchy Asshole" and I have a bit on my first CD called "Itchy Asshole" I'm not going to court over a bit called "itchy asshole"”
– Louis CK discussing the stolen jokes and whether he’ll seek legal action.
“jesus. i just heard that one. Okay, this kid is stealing from me. And making lots of money. Three bits on one cd... Oh well. Whatever.”
– Louis CK after listening to the joke about naming kids a confusing string of letters.
The moral of the story is Dane Cook is a brilliant marketer and performer, but that's about it. If you disagree, listen to Louis, Hedberg, Todd Barry, Daniel Tosh, Mike Birbiglia, Jim Gaffigan or Brian Regan.
<-->